Cayuga Real Estate Search

Cayuga Single Family Properties for Sale

Our website features the best real estate search for single family properties available in Cayuga and surrounding areas. It is the only site you will ever need! It is easy-to-use and updated by the official REALTOR®’s database every 15 minutes. 

You can save searches, and get daily email alerts of new listings, price changes, sold data, and market reports. Our Interactive Map Search allows you to view properties on a map or refine your search by drawing the boundaries around the area you desire.

Considering selling or refinancing your home? Get an INSTANT property valuation now!

Newest Cayuga Single Family Homes for Sale

2064 RIVER Road, Cayuga
$5,500,000
4 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ 40870865 MLS® #
GRAND RIVER WATERFRONT MASTERPIECE! Experience an extraordinary level of luxury on this spectacular 20.61ac Grand River estate, enjoying over 2000ft of river frontage & more than 21 miles of navigable water at your doorstep. Custom built in 2023, this magnificent all-stone “Villa” offers nearly 6000sf of finished living space, impeccable craftsmanship & exceptional amenities thru-out. Spectacular principal rooms, soaring 22ft post & beam ceilings, incredible “World Class” kitchen & impressive walk-out lower level boasting 9ft ceilings incs stunning second kitchen - set the stage for delightful entertaining. In-floor heating thru-out entire lower level, main floor ensuite & 3-car garage, plus n/gas heating & central air, deliver year-round comfort. Over 770sf of elevated composite decking overlooks stamped concrete terraces, lushly landscaped gardens & heated in-ground pool. The ultimate entertainment experience continues in 2023 constructed 44'x80' stone clad building, featuring professionally finished “Man Cave” sporting gorgeous kitchen, 2-pc bath, epoxy covered in-floor heating, air conditioning, 1600sf of finished garage space incs multiple roll-up doors & 11ft ceilings plus 900sf/50ft long RV parking bay ftrs 14ft roll-up door. At the river’s edge, a beachie tiki building w/retractable front opening & expansive concrete patios create an unforgettable waterfront retreat. Impressive automatic entry gates, paved driveway w/concrete accents, outdoor irrigation, indoor/outdoor audio, security & over $1 million invested in landscaping complete this remarkable venue. Over $100,000 in EZ Docks makes boating, paddle boarding, canoeing, kayaking or jet skiing effortless. An exceptional waterfront resort-style property where luxury, recreation & “Grand” scale entertaining come together. 40 mins S. of Hamilton/10 mins to Cayuga. Simply Surreal - No Expense Spared - where waterfront adventure, uncompromising luxury & world-class entertaining become your everyday lifestyle! (id:5764)

2064 RIVER Road, Cayuga

Listing courtesy of RE/MAX Escarpment Realty Inc..

22 MCKAY Street, Cayuga
$479,000
4 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 40872649 MLS® #
BEAUTIFULLY PRESENTED CAYUGA BUNGALOW ON A SOUGHT-AFTER DEAD-END STREET! Ideally located in a desirable, family-friendly neighbourhood, this inviting 3+1 bedroom, 2 bathroom bungalow offers the perfect blend of comfort, functionality, and move-in-ready appeal. Custom built in 1996, this well-maintained home boasts excellent curb appeal with tasteful landscaping, a classic brick and siding exterior, and an oversized driveway. The fully fenced backyard is ideal for relaxing and entertaining, featuring an exposed aggregate walkway and patio. Step inside to discover a flowing, functional layout with numerous updates throughout, including oak kitchen cabinetry, a separate dining area, and a spacious main-floor living room enhanced by rich laminate flooring. A refreshed 4-piece bathroom and generously sized primary bedroom complete the main level. The partially finished basement extends the living space beautifully, ready for you to put your final touches on.. featuring a recreation room illuminated by extensive pot lighting, an additional bedroom, and an impressive 3-piece bathroom with a tiled walk-in shower and custom vanity. Enjoy the convenience of being just steps from downtown Cayuga, shopping, parks, schools, the arena, and the Grand River. Commuters will appreciate the easy access to Hamilton, Highway 403, and the QEW, approximately 30 minutes away. An excellent opportunity to enjoy comfortable bungalow living in a fantastic location, with the updates already done! Simply move in, unpack, and enjoy all this wonderful Cayuga home has to offer. Don't miss your opportunity to make it yours! (id:5764)

22 MCKAY Street, Cayuga

Listing courtesy of RE/MAX Escarpment Realty Inc..

1140 RIVER Road, Cayuga
$1,599,900
3 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ 40869461 MLS® #
Luxury Riverfront Living on the Grand River! A home & cottage all in one! Truly Irreplaceable 2.46 acre Cayuga Estate property showcasing a Custom Built 3 bedroom, 3 bathroom Bungalow with full walk out basement with breathtaking Waterview’s. Incredible curb appeal with all brick exterior, paved driveway with ample parking, stamped concrete walkway leading to welcoming covered porch, entertainers dream backyard Oasis with upper level composite deck, on grade lower level stamped concrete patio area with hot tub, outdoor TV, stone fireplace, & 2 outdoor heaters. The exquisitely updated interior features the perfect blend of function & elegance with over 4000 sq ft of open concept living space highlighted by wide plank hardwood flooring throughout, gorgeous eat in kitchen with quartz countertops & backsplash, & island, formal dining area with coffered ceilings, living room featuring built in corner fireplace, 3 spacious MF bedrooms including primary suite with large walk in closet & lavish 3 pc ensuite with tile walk in shower, primary 4 pc bathroom, & MF laundry. The full walk out basement allows for Ideal in law suite & large rec room with fireplace, games area, den, 3 pc bathroom, & cold cellar, & utility area. Recent upgrades include kitchen, hardwood flooring, bathrooms, roof shingles – 2022, furnace, A/C, & HWH – 2023, water softener & UV system – 2022. Conveniently located minutes to Cayuga amenities & relaxing commute to Hamilton, 403, & QEW. Over 20 km of navigable water allowing you to boat, wakeboard, fish, & kayak right from your own backyard. Grand River Living is more than a place to call home – It’s a Lifestyle you deserve to Experience. Luxury Certified! (id:5764)

1140 RIVER Road, Cayuga

Listing courtesy of RE/MAX Escarpment Realty Inc..

147 CONCESSION 1 Road South, Cayuga
$999,000
4 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 40857106 MLS® #
Desirable 4 acre rural property fronting on Cayuga’s sought after, extremely popular Concession 1 Road South - known for it’s close knit neighborhood - relaxing 25 min commute to Hamilton, Brantford & 403 near Grand River. Nestled magically under towering pines & hardwoods is custom designed, 1986 built, 2 storey home offering finished walk-out basement complimented with 370sf elevated front deck, 360sf side deck & 24ft AG pool incs 288sf deck - the perfect venue to savor this park-like rear yard showcasing natural pond surrounded by young pine forest. Introduces over 1900sf of country themed living area ftrs open concept living room w/16ft ceilings + reclaimed brick wood-burning fireplace, adjacent dinette incs garden door deck WO, 4 pc bath, main floor primary bedroom, galley-style kitchen sporting SS built-in appliances + direct entry to 1.5 car garage. Loft-style upper level overlooks main floor and provides entry to 2 roomy bedrooms + 3pc bath. Basement level family room enjoys wood stove plus patio door walk-out, 4th bedroom & large laundry/utility room. Extras - p/g furnace/AC, metal roof, 200 amp hydro service + 5000g cistern. Need an Escape…check out 29’x25’ “HE/SHE” Shop w/concrete floor & roll-up door + 12x28 lean-to. Handy auxiliary buildings inc 10x16 vinyl sided shed + 16x18 storage building. Sold 'AS IS under Chargee/Mortgagee in his Capacity under Power of Sale. Natural Unblemished Beauty…Seldom Seen…Rarely Available! (id:5764)

147 CONCESSION 1 Road South, Cayuga

Listing courtesy of RE/MAX Escarpment Realty Inc..

1300 RIVER Road, Cayuga
$1,049,900
3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 40851943 MLS® #
Exceptional Grand River Waterfront Opportunity! The best of both worlds – a cottage and home all in one! This custom designed & 2017 built home features meticulous attention to detail throughout this masterfully planned layout and is situated on “Muskoka” Like 128’ x 140’ lot nestled at the end of a lane with over 20 km of navigable water allowing you to boat, wakeboard, fish, kayak & enjoy all that Grand River Living has to offer right from your own backyard. The perfect mix of privacy, peacefulness, & a natural waterfront setting. Great curb appeal with premium sided exterior, welcoming front covered porch, back entertaining deck, easy access to the water, & sought after 25’ x 38’ detached garage with concrete floor, hydro, & separate entrance to finish able loft area to add to your overall living space – opportunity galore. The flowing interior layout emphasizes the stunning waterview’s from almost every room and is highlighted by open concept interior featuring custom “DeBoer” kitchen cabinetry with large island, gorgeous hickory staircase, dining area, living room, desired MF bedroom, 3 pc bathroom, & welcoming foyer. The upper level features primary suite overlooking the water, additional 4 pc bathroom, laundry room, & 3rd bedroom. The unfinished lower level includes ample storage & utility area. Upgrades include high-end flooring throughout, modern decor, custom heating & A/C system for year round comfort, water filtration system, & custom blinds. Conveniently located minutes to Cayuga & Dunnville – easy access to 403, QEW, Niagara, & GTA. Absolutely no work to do – just move in & Enjoy! Call today for private viewing of this Exceptional Cayuga Waterfront Home & Experience Grand River Living! (id:5764)

1300 RIVER Road, Cayuga

Listing courtesy of RE/MAX Escarpment Realty Inc..

1001 HALDIMAND Road Unit 35, Cayuga
$73,900
1 Beds ⋅ 1 Baths ⋅ 40852153 MLS® #
Welcome to Grand River RV Resort in beautiful Cayuga, just 30 minutes south of Hamilton! Enjoy affordable seasonal cottage living in this move-in ready 2020 Forest River Salem Grand Villa 42FLDL destination trailer, offering approximately 400 sq. ft. of living space with 3 slide-outs, measuring 41 ft. 7 in. x 8 ft. 6 in. This spacious unit features 1 bedroom, 2 lofts, a 3-piece bathroom, an open-concept living area, residential-style kitchen with ample cabinetry, a propane forced-air furnace, and an owned water heater. Step outside to the covered wrap-around deck, perfect for relaxing or entertaining, with the BBQ, outdoor furniture, shed, and most contents included, making this a true turnkey opportunity. The property also offers grass/gravel parking for approximately 3 vehicles, with visitor parking conveniently located nearby. Set within the picturesque 130+ acre Grand River RV Resort, owners enjoy a relaxing cottage and camping lifestyle with access to the Grand River, nearby boat launch, park, campground, and mini putt, along with two heated saltwater community pools and beautifully maintained grounds. The annual land lease is approximately $5,000 and includes water and sewer, while hydro is additional at approximately $300 per year. Whether you're searching for a peaceful summer retreat, a weekend escape, or an affordable cottage alternative, this exceptional property offers the perfect opportunity to relax, unwind, and create lasting memories. (id:5764)

1001 HALDIMAND Road Unit 35, Cayuga

Listing courtesy of RE/MAX Escarpment Realty Inc..

27 CAYUGA Street North, Cayuga
$649,900
6 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ 40831056 MLS® #
Excellent opportunity to get into the real estate market here at 27 Cayuga St. N, Cayuga. Real Estate Investors wanting to purchase a turn-key, fully occupied legal duplex generating $60,600 gross annual income - today is your lucky day! Includes an extensively recently renovated, from bottom to top, 2 storey building positioned proudly on 0.18 acre lot in the heart of downtown Cayuga - no car required for tenants, as all amenities this popular Grand River offers, are within walking distance - incs shops, eateries, Post Office, river parks, schools & churches. UNIT #1 - Main Floor apartment ftrs 9ft ceilings highlighted w/open concept living area & stylish white kitchen cabinetry sporting designer island, quartz countertops & SS appliances incs built-in dishwasher, primary bedroom enjoying 3pc en-suite, 4pc principal bath, 2 additional bedrooms, laundry facilities & patio door walk-out to rear deck & yard. UNIT #2 - 2nd Floor apartment enjoys side door entrance w/private enclosed staircase accessing open concept living area & modern white kitchen augmented w/SS appliances incs built-in dishwasher & quartz countertops, 3 large bedrooms, 4pc main bath & separate laundry station. Extras - new since 2023 - low maintenance vinyl flooring thru-out, n/g furnace/AC, windows, 100 amp electrical/plumbing/insulation/drywall & LED lighting - plus double paved driveway & quaint wrap around front/side porch. Buyer agrees to accept the current Tenants upon completion of this transaction. Cap Rate of “7” (approx). Relaxing 30/40 min commute to Hamilton, Brantford & Hwy 403 - 90/120 mins to GTA. Rare Maintenance Free Duplex Package! (id:5764)

27 CAYUGA Street North, Cayuga

Listing courtesy of RE/MAX Escarpment Realty Inc..

35 OTTAWA Street South, Cayuga
$624,900
6 Beds ⋅ 1 Baths ⋅ 40828428 MLS® #
Envision an era in history when everything in life was simpler and people had time for each other - you will feel yesteryear’s magical vibes as you enter this well maintained property located at 35 Ottawa St. South situated in Cayuga’s preferred, established southwest quadrant. Offering close proximity to all of this Grand River town’s popular amenities incs schools, churches, arena/walking track complex, new Municipal Building, downtown shops, eateries, shopping, Grand River park pavilion & boat launch - 30 mins to Hamilton, Brantford & Hwy 403. Positioned proudly on 0.20ac lot is lovingly cared for frame-style century home (circa 1880) wearing a fresh coat of brilliant white exterior paint-2025 - enjoying 82.90ft of quiet side street frontage introducing 1,830sf of above grade living area, 878sf unspoiled basement level - plus 500sf of non-heated, west wing main floor area, requiring minimal cost to finish increasing square footage substantially. Sparkling new 290sf side entertainment deck-2025 provides entry to beautifully preserved 3-season’s sun porch leading to country-sized kitchen accented with gorgeous original hardwood flooring extending to adjacent living room, spacious family room & versatile office with bedroom potential. Similar style hardwood flooring compliment 4 upper level bedrooms & roomy corridor culminating at east end man door walk-out to 8x12 recently constructed Juliet balcony-2025 - matching similar sized grade level front deck promoting a stately street presence. Extensive use of pine tongue & groove walls/vaulted ceilings accent rustic inspired primary bedroom incs 183sf attached room, suitable for nursery or massive walk-in closet & adjacent large storage attic. Service style basement houses efficient gas hot water heater/boiler-2015 providing economical radiant heat source. Extras - all appliances, paved double driveway, 100 amp hydro (all knob & tube removed in 2015) & wood perimeter fencing-2025. “Timeless Character & Charm!” (id:5764)

35 OTTAWA Street South, Cayuga

Listing courtesy of RE/MAX Escarpment Realty Inc..

1042 RIVER Road, Cayuga
$874,900
3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 40818750 MLS® #
Spectacular waterfront property enjoying 186ft of coveted low profile/easy access Grand River frontage incs over 22 miles of navigable waterway at your doorstep. Savour tranquil views of the meandering Grand enjoying views of undisturbed natural lands across deep/wide portion of river - the ultimate venue for boating, waterskiing, canoeing, kayaking or fishing - wildlife & exotic waterfowl sanctuary. Follow flag stone walk-way accented with beautiful landscaping to front entry of updated 2 storey Cape Cod style home boasting over 1900sf of open concept living/dining area offering oversized water-view windows - continues to modern kitchen sporting ample cabinetry + walk-out to private 10x20 river facing deck, 3pc bath & convenient direct garage entry. Multiple classic dormers ensure an abundance of natural light flooding the spacious upper level incs roomy hallway, elegant primary bedroom enhanced with 2 river-view windows & 4 double door closets + 2 additional bedrooms. Easy access staircase provides entry to 874sf lower level/basement introduces rec/family room, laundry/utility room + handy storage area. Incs 3 parcels with separate ARN’s - new government legislature may allow for potential future lot severance - sufficient area for auxiliary dwelling (ADU), tiny house or outbuilding/barnette. Relaxing 30/40 min commute to Hamilton, Brantford & Hwy 403 - 10 mins SW of Cayuga - less than 120 mins south of GTA. Extras - furnace-2014, AC-2023, c/vac, new vinyl windows-2024, roof shingles-2008, appliances, 2000 gal. cistern + septic. Unbeatable combination of incredible lot size & substantial water frontage. Life is Grander on the Grand! (id:5764)

1042 RIVER Road, Cayuga

Listing courtesy of RE/MAX Escarpment Realty Inc..

Start Your Search

How much is your home worth?

Get instant property value now!